Author Archives: Sharon A. Hill

About Sharon A. Hill

Strange Claims Adjuster and Spooky Geologist On Mastodon at @idoubtit@mstdn.social

Animal Planet’s Monster Week tones down the hype for 2016

By | May 23, 2016

It’s business as usual at Animal Planet channel. It’s Monster Week. You know, it’s not that bad to air shows like The Cannibal in the Jungle for one week or on occasion. But AnPlan has gone too far in the past several years by suggesting that mermaids, Megalodon and cryptids exist by co-opting bad or outright… Read More: Animal Planet’s Monster Week tones down the hype for 2016 »

End of an era: the last Skeptic’s Dictionary newsletter

By | May 22, 2016

Dr. Robert T. Carroll created the Skeptic’s Dictionary – a source I have used for, oh gosh, over 10 years now. I was upset to hear of Bob’s serious illness. I consider Skepdic.com to be a PRIMARY go to source for skeptical reference. With nearly 800 entries, I have, by default, linked to his site for… Read More: End of an era: the last Skeptic’s Dictionary newsletter »

Well-worn paranormal paths go nowhere: When to give up

By | May 12, 2016

Gary Campbell is the keeper of the Official Sightings Register at Loch Ness. In an article today in the Daily Record, he says that even after 20 years of this project, sightings still continue. Gary Campbell, keeper of the register, said the fascination of Nessie was showing no signs of abating. He accepted five sightings for… Read More: Well-worn paranormal paths go nowhere: When to give up »

The Bigfoot Book: Speculation and supernatural but no skepticism

By | April 28, 2016

Nick Redfern’s latest, The Bigfoot Book, has a sound premise and great potential. It’s all about stuff you may never have heard about or saw relating to the Bigfoot phenomena. This is a collection of small articles on topics related to the Bigfoot phenomenon – an “encyclopedia” (though not comprehensive by any means) written in… Read More: The Bigfoot Book: Speculation and supernatural but no skepticism »

Book review: Margery and Houdini story reveals gaps, not answers

By | April 26, 2016

A review of The Witch of Lime Street: Séance, Seduction, and Houdini in the Spirit World by David Jaher This is a story of Spiritualism in America in the early 1920s. The darling of the psychic scene was Margery (a faux name) intended to hide the identity of Mina Stinson Crandon, a young, outgoing wife… Read More: Book review: Margery and Houdini story reveals gaps, not answers »

Paranormal investigators and Velikovsky sound similarly sciencey

By | April 20, 2016

In January 2013, I wrote about Immanuel Velikovsky, Worlds in Collision, and pseudoscience, referencing Michael Gordin’s excellent book The Pseudoscience Wars (2012). Well, I’m writing about it again, to be included in a book about amateur investigation groups “sounding sciencey” and fooling the public. I went back to some of my old sources and found a good one. It’s… Read More: Paranormal investigators and Velikovsky sound similarly sciencey »

Dreaming of DNA: Review of Sykes’ Bigfoot, Yeti and the last Neanderthal

By | March 31, 2016

Originally published in the UK as The Nature of the Beast, Oxford geneticist Bryan Sykes’ Bigfoot, Yeti and the Last Neanderthal: A geneticist’s search for modern apemen is highly enjoyable and reveals a bunch of interesting tidbits as well as showing us some rather personal insights and new facts from the professor who attempted to bring credibility to the study of hairy… Read More: Dreaming of DNA: Review of Sykes’ Bigfoot, Yeti and the… »

They must have changed the definition of “true”: The Conjuring 2

By | March 28, 2016

So, I just watched the trailer for The Conjuring 2 in which crack self-righteous demonologists Ed and Lorraine Warren investigate the Enfield poltergeist case in the U.K. It begins by stating the story is based on the “true case files” of the Warrens. Yeah, no. Nothing about this is “true” in the conventional sense of the… Read More: They must have changed the definition of “true”: The Conjuring… »

The State of the Science: Parapsychology (Book Review)

By | March 11, 2016

In October of last year I wrote a blog post about a review of a new parapsychology compendium. Finally, I’ve gotten to read the entire book referenced for myself, cover to cover, 400+ pages. Parapsychology: A Handbook for the 21st Century (2015) edited by Etzel Cardeña, John Palmer, David Marcusson-Clavertz It took about 7 weeks… Read More: The State of the Science: Parapsychology (Book Review) »

A Guide to Ghost Hunting Guidebooks: NO MORE! Please!

By | January 16, 2016

This might come as a shock to the millions of ghost enthusiasts out there: The scientific consensus is that ghosts are NOT spirits, remnants of the dead, recordings of energy, or supernatural entities. Our existing knowledge about nature does not point to a conclusion that ghosts are a single definable thing, paranormal or normal, that you… Read More: A Guide to Ghost Hunting Guidebooks: NO MORE! Please! »

Book Review: Dawkins’ Brief Candle

By | December 29, 2015

Brief Candle in the Dark: My Life in Science by Richard Dawkins My rating: 4 of 5 stars I feel this book helped me understand Dawkins considerably more than I did previously. It also deepened my appreciation for him and his life’s work – in zoology, evolutionary biology, religion, philosophy, and science in society. There… Read More: Book Review: Dawkins’ Brief Candle »

Trust No One: All news is doubtful

By | December 22, 2015

Note: All links to Doubtful News are dead.  My main project, Doubtful News is on hiatus right now. (Update 22-Jan-2016: We’re back.) Honestly, it’s because I don’t have the motivation to keep up with the onslaught of questionable claims that are in the media. Twice this week, I was reminded by others of the following:… Read More: Trust No One: All news is doubtful »

The stupidiocy of Ancient Aliens for kids (Book Review)

By | December 4, 2015

There are few good skeptical books for kids. But there are a shit-ton of terrible books promoting mystery and pseudoscientific nonsense aimed at kids or those getting started exploring a paranormal topic. I often peruse the 001 section of Juvenile Literature in the library. Mostly, I’m sickened. Occasionally, I’m surprised. There is a need for better… Read More: The stupidiocy of Ancient Aliens for kids (Book Review) »

Media as ‘medium’: Review of Paranormal Media and the good and bad of ghost hunting

By | November 6, 2015

It’s not news that the paranormal is mainstream, which is ironic since we commonly understand the paranormal to be events that are NOT normal yet the discussion about it is an everyday occurrence. If you follow TV ghost hunters or paranormal researchers, “evidence” is all around us. So much for it being all that “extraordinary”.… Read More: Media as ‘medium’: Review of Paranormal Media and the good… »

Miscellaneous book review quickies Fall 2015

By | November 1, 2015

The Paranormal by Kenneth PartridgeMy rating: 1 of 5 stars Mostly poor choice of selections for this collection. It’s a book marketed to university libraries as a “resource” but not worth it. Teachers would do far better finding their own readings online. Paranormal Media by Annette HillMy rating: 2 of 5 stars Some interesting ideas… Read More: Miscellaneous book review quickies Fall 2015 »

Parapsychology continues to fail to impress reviewers

By | October 18, 2015

A correspondent clued me in to what he called a “devastating commentary on parapsychology.” I agree. The review on the Magonia Review of Books meshes with what I had written in June 2014 when I looked into parapsychology, comparing then and now. It’s helpful to see an independent critique that notes the same flaws as you did. I’m not the… Read More: Parapsychology continues to fail to impress reviewers »

“True Jersey” NJ.com published a stinker of a story on the Jersey Devil

By | October 13, 2015

A paranormal investigator who writes a column called Paranormal Corner for NJ.com broke a story this weekend that was both a coup for web hits and an utter disaster for her credibility. Kelly Roncace received an email with a photo of what the sender said was the Jersey Devil. The JD is one of the… Read More: “True Jersey” NJ.com published a stinker of a story on… »

If you think Bigfoot is an interdimensional being, you’ve lost your footing

By | October 6, 2015

A person making an extraordinary claim may feel very special. A couple that I met recently who do paranormal research described some acquaintances’ behavior during an investigation of a supposedly haunted place : a woman “swooned” as the spirit overcame her. It was all very dramatic, they said. I’ve seen similar when one ghost hunter of a… Read More: If you think Bigfoot is an interdimensional being, you’ve lost… »

Cryptozoology and Myth, Part 5: Which came first – the monster or the myth?

By | September 29, 2015

This is the fifth and final post in a series examining cryptids (“hidden” animals said to exist based on local testimony), namely lake monsters, in terms of the folklore, tradition, and native tales of these creatures. Previous parts: Cryptozoology and Myth, Part 1: The Illusion of Facticity in Unknown Animal Reports Cryptozoology and Myth, Part 2:… Read More: Cryptozoology and Myth, Part 5: Which came first – the… »

Houdini. Skeptic. (Book Review)

By | September 18, 2015

Harry Houdini needs no introduction, but there are several facts that people do not know about this consummate skeptic. That makes this book a must for everyone interested in psychics and paranormal claims. Just the Introduction to this great book floored me. How much we needed Houdini at the time. How much we STILL need… Read More: Houdini. Skeptic. (Book Review) »